What to Do When a DBS Check Returns a Conviction

Receiving a DBS check result that includes a criminal conviction can feel uncertain, particularly if you have not been in this situation before. However, a disclosed conviction does not automatically mean a candidate is unsuitable for the role. What matters most is how you respond to that information and whether your process is fair, consistent, and legally sound.

This guide is written for employers across the UK who want to handle DBS disclosures properly, whether they are running DBS checks online for a single hire or managing DBS checks for employers across a large organisation. It walks through each stage of the process in plain language, from understanding what you are looking at to making a final decision with confidence.

Understanding What a DBS Check Actually Shows

Before reacting to a conviction on a disclosure certificate, it helps to understand what each type of DBS check reveals and why that matters.

If you use a DBS online service in the United Kingdom, there are three levels of check available:

  • Basic DBS check – shows unspent convictions only; available to anyone and can be applied for as an individual DBS check
  • Standard DBS check – shows both spent and unspent convictions, cautions, reprimands, and warnings
  • Enhanced DBS check – includes everything in the Standard check, plus any relevant information held by local police, and in many cases a check against the Children’s Barred List or Adults’ Barred List

The Enhanced DBS check is commonly required for roles in teaching, childcare, healthcare, and social work, especially where work involves children or vulnerable adults.

Understanding which level of check was done and what it covers is key to correctly interpreting a DBS result.

Step 1: Do Not Treat a Conviction as an Automatic Disqualifier

Employers should not automatically withdraw job offers when a conviction appears, as decisions must be based on proper assessment rather than caution alone. The Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 protects people with spent convictions, which may not need to be disclosed depending on the role and DBS level.

For regulated roles requiring enhanced DBS checks, such as schools or childcare, convictions must be reviewed carefully. However, even in these cases, decisions should focus on relevance to the job rather than rejecting candidates automatically.

Step 2: Assess the Relevance of the Conviction to the Role

The central question in any fair assessment is whether the disclosed conviction is relevant to the responsibilities of the job.

Here are the key factors to consider:

  • What was the nature of the offence?
  • How long ago did it take place?
  • Was it a single incident or part of a repeated pattern of behaviour?
  • Has the individual shown evidence of rehabilitation or changed circumstances since?
  • Does the offence relate directly to the duties of the role being applied for?

A minor motoring conviction from ten years ago is usually not relevant to an office-based role, but it may matter more for transport or delivery jobs. Offences from someone’s youth may also carry less weight, especially if they now have a stable work history and positive record since then.

Relevance is assessed differently depending on the sector. For example:

  • For DBS checks for working in schools or a DBS check for teachers, any offence involving children or dishonesty would carry significant weight
  • For childcare DBS checks in the UK, including DBS checking for nursery staff and a DBS for childminders, offences involving harm, deception, or drugs would be closely scrutinised
  • For a self-employed DBS check or DBS check for self-employed individuals in care roles, the same safeguarding principles apply as they would for employed staff

Step 3: Carry Out a Structured Risk Assessment

Once you have identified the relevant factors, the next step is to formalise your thinking through a written risk assessment. This is good practice for all employers and essential in regulated sectors.

Your risk assessment should cover:

  • A description of the offence as shown on the DBS certificate
  • The relevance of the offence to the specific role and its responsibilities
  • The time elapsed since the offence and any mitigating circumstances
  • Evidence of rehabilitation or changed behaviour
  • Whether the risk posed can be managed through supervision, support, or other safeguards

The table below summarises how different types of offences might be considered across common sectors:

SectorDBS Level RequiredKey Risk Factors to Assess
Schools and educationEnhanced with Barred ListOffences involving children, dishonesty, violence
Nurseries and childmindersEnhanced with Barred ListOffences involving children, drugs, neglect
Care and social workEnhanced with Barred ListViolence, exploitation, financial abuse
Charities working with vulnerable groupsEnhancedOffences relevant to the charity’s beneficiaries
Self-employed in regulated rolesEnhancedRole-specific risk based on nature of work
General employmentBasic or StandardRelevance to specific job duties

Involving more than one person in the review process helps reduce unconscious bias and ensures the decision is not made by a single individual acting alone.

You are also visit our office for further information about DBS checks and the services we provide.

Step 4: Give the Candidate a Chance to Respond

Before rejecting a candidate because of a disclosed conviction, it is important to give them an opportunity to provide context. A private and professional discussion can help you understand the circumstances of the offence, any rehabilitation efforts, and the individual’s situation since the conviction.

This ensures decisions are based on complete information rather than the DBS certificate alone. Taking a fair and respectful approach also demonstrates your organisation’s commitment to responsible and ethical recruitment practices.

Step 5: Keep a Clear and Confidential Record

Documentation is essential throughout this process. Keep a confidential record of:

  • The information disclosed on the DBS certificate
  • Notes from any conversation held with the candidate about the disclosure
  • Your written risk assessment and the factors considered
  • The final decision and the reasoning behind it

Keeping a record of your decision helps show that your recruitment process was fair and compliant. It can also protect your organisation if the decision is later questioned.

DBS information should only be shared with authorised individuals and stored securely in line with data protection laws.

Step 6: Make a Decision Based on Risk, Not Reaction

After reviewing the individual DBS check and speaking with the candidate, you can make an informed decision. The decision should be based on the actual risk relevant to the role, rather than concerns about perception or the difficulty of the conversation.

If you decide to proceed with the appointment:

  • Consider whether any additional supervision or support would be appropriate during an initial period
  • Ensure that anyone involved in safeguarding oversight is aware of the relevant background
  • Review the arrangement at agreed intervals if needed

If you decide not to proceed:

  • Inform the candidate respectfully and clearly
  • Explain the reasoning in broad terms without disclosing more information than necessary
  • Let them know whether there may be scope to apply again in future, if that is genuinely the case

In either outcome, the process you have followed should reflect well on your organisation.

When to Seek Additional Guidance

There are situations where independent guidance is advisable before making a final decision:

  • Where you are unsure whether a conviction legally disqualifies a candidate from a regulated role
  • Where the candidate disputes the accuracy of the DBS certificate
  • Where the role involves DBS checks for working with children or other regulated activity and the conviction is directly related to that work
  • Where your organisation does not have an internal HR or legal team to advise on complex cases

Sector-specific regulators, legal advisors, and professional vetting providers can all offer relevant guidance. Using an established DBS online service for the United Kingdom also means you have access to expertise if questions arise during or after the checking process.

Sectors With Specific Considerations

Schools and Teaching

DBS checks for schools and teachers must be at the Enhanced level and include a Children’s Barred List check. Any convictions involving children, violence, or dishonesty should be assessed carefully before employment begins.

Nurseries and Childcare

DBS checks for nursery staff, childcare workers, and childminders must be Enhanced level. Safeguarding young children is the primary consideration when reviewing any disclosed convictions.

Charities

DBS checks for charity workers and volunteers may be required, particularly when working with vulnerable groups. Any conviction should be assessed in relation to the role and the people being supported.

Self-Employed Individuals

Self-employed individuals can obtain a Basic DBS check independently. Those working in regulated roles may require an Enhanced check through a registered umbrella body, with convictions assessed according to the responsibilities of the role.

Online DBS Checks | What to Do When a DBS Check Returns a Conviction

The DBS Update Service: Ongoing Compliance for Employers

The DBS Update Service helps employers check whether a DBS certificate remains current without requiring a new application. This can save time and support compliance, particularly in sectors such as education, care, and charities. To use the service, individuals must register within 30 days of their DBS certificate being issued.

For further guidance on DBS checks and the services we offer, feel free to visit our office and speak with a member of our team.

Conclusion

A disclosed conviction on a DBS check should be assessed fairly and in the context of the role. Employers should consider the relevance of the conviction, allow the candidate to provide an explanation, and document their decision-making process.

For roles requiring Enhanced DBS checks, such as those involving children or vulnerable groups, additional scrutiny may be needed. However, a conviction should be the starting point of an assessment, not an automatic reason for rejection.

Using a trusted DBS service and clear policies helps ensure decisions are fair, consistent, and legally compliant. For more information about DBS checks and our services, contact us today. Our experienced team is happy to assist with any questions you may have.

Frequently Asked Questions

A Standard DBS check shows spent and unspent convictions, while an Enhanced DBS check also includes relevant police information and, where applicable, barred list checks.

Enhanced DBS checks must be requested through an employer or registered umbrella body, usually via an online application process.

Yes. Eligible self-employed individuals in regulated roles can obtain an Enhanced DBS check through a registered umbrella body.

Record the conviction details, any discussion with the candidate, your risk assessment, and the reasons for your final decision.

DBS certificates should generally not be kept for more than six months, unless there is a legal reason to do so.

Author

Tagged with: , , , , , ,
Posted in blog, DBS Check